2017-01-13

Removing Chromatic Aberration with ACDSee Pro 10

I have recently downloaded a trial version of the new ACDSee Pro 10. To be honest, I wasn´t expecting too much. I have used version 6 for quite a while but when I started shooting in Raw I switched to Lightroom because it is so much better in many ways. One of the things that I missed in ACDSee was the ability to automatically fix chromatic aberration. They provided sliders to manually fix it but - seriously - if you come back from holidays with 1000+ photos, would you really want to fix CA manually in all of them. I have to admit that I am also not really satisfied with Adobe´s way to handle that. They provide automatic CA removal (based on lens profiles or image analysis - I don´t know) with no option to manually fine tune it.
Well anyway, I think it was in version 9 when ACDSee introduced lens profiles, including CA removal (at least for some lenses). I have tested it and wasn´t really satisfied with the result. Now I tested it again in version 10. To be honest, I didn´t spend much time on the test. I just picked one of photos which shows some beautiful CA (and for which ACDSee can provide a lens profile) and activated the CA checkbox.
I would like to share the results with you. First of all, let´s have a look at the original image, without CA correction applied. The screenshot below shows ACDSee with the phot of a mountain. The photo was taken with a canon 6D with the EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM lens attached. Of course it was taken in raw format. Without correction applied you can easily see the strong red fringes at the edge of the rock.

ACDSee - no CA correction applied

Now let´s see how ACDSee fixes the issue. Obviously, it does something. But I have to say, the result is quite frustrating. The image is now equally bad as before - except cyan is your favourite colour. The correction that has been applied was a little too strong. Instead of red fringes we now have cyan fringes. And they are almost as wide as the original red ones. Well, my rating is very subjective, but I think the image quality has not been improved at all.
ACDSee - CA correction applied


Now  let´s do the same thing in Lightroom and see if we can identify any difference. Again, the first screenshot shows the original photo without CA correction.
Lightroom - no CA correction applied

And finally, here´s the Lightroom Image with CA correction applied.
Lightroom - CA correction applied



It is easy to see that Lightroom removed CA far better than ACDSee. It is still not perfect but I can live with that. In a normal sized print I´m pretty sure you wouldn´t be able to recognize any color finges in the Lightroom photo but you would most probably be able to see them in the ACDSee photo.

UPDATE
I´ve claimed this in ACDSee´s forum and learned that the reason is, that there is no lens profile available for the lens I was using. Well, I would expect that it is not possible to activate the checkbox if no profile is available.





1 comment:

  1. ACDSee Coupon
    If you order at least two products via Element5, the coupon isn’t applied to the very first item. Therefore, to get the very best performance from your multimedia experience, you may use the merchandise of ACDSee. That you are going to be in a position to activate the item on more than 1 computer. You will locate the very best suitable products for your need from the selection of the website. It is among those brands and it’s an extremely popular one also.

    ReplyDelete